As I have mentioned when I did a post on NYX casting call, NYX Smokey Eyes and NYX Casting Call are pretty similar almost identical if we skip we shades on NYX Smokey Eyes Palette
If they had Casting Call those days when I purchased NYX Smokey Eyes I would probably buy Casting Call,
It is pretty strong and this is a proper Smokey eyes palette, When I wear Smokey Eyes I use dark shades, dark blacks and this is really good, it is still dusty and that is the weakest point of NYX eye shadow palettes and eye shadows they are really dusty and I always have to swipe the remains with a fan brush.. I have a spare fan brush for those purposes I use Benefit Fan Brush it is small and pretty handy for sweeping eye shadow remains,